Bagelista Everything Bagels
Bring the bagel shop home. | 4 Servings
- Sesame
- Wheat
Everyone knows that some of the best bagels come from the Big Apple. Now you can enjoy New York bagels no matter where you are! Bagelista’s flavor-packed everything bagels (coated with onions, garlic, poppy, sesame, and rye) are made from scratch in New York City, kettle boiled, and partially baked all before arriving at your door. They did all the hard work, so you can enjoy those glossy-on-the-outside/ chewy-on-the-inside bagels fresh from your own kitchen. That’s what we call a breakfast of champions! *Nutrition values are representative of one bagel.*
Ingredients
4 piece
Everything Bagels
(Contains: Sesame, Wheat)
Cooking Steps
Keep frozen until ready to eat. (TIP: Do not microwave.)
OVEN OR TOASTER OVEN: Preheat oven to 425 degrees. Place on a baking sheet; bake until golden brown, 7-10 minutes. (Note: Oven times may vary.)
AIR FRYER: Arrange bagels side by side in an air fryer basket (you may have to work in batches). Air fry at 400 degrees until golden brown, 4-5 minutes. (Note: Air fryer times may vary).
Let cool 2-3 minutes before slicing.
Customer reviews
Review summary
Updated on Feb 2026- Flavor: Many loved the authentic, fresh-baked taste; some found them bland and wanted more seasoning.
- Ease of prep: Air fryer method was popular for quick, crispy results; some were surprised by needing to bake them.
- Suggestions: Consider pre-slicing the bagels and packing them on top to avoid squishing during shipping.
- Leftovers: Several noted they freeze well, but some found them less tasty after the first day.
- Texture: Customers praised the crispy outside and soft, chewy inside when prepared correctly 🥯.
Reviews from our home cooks
These bagels are everything you need in a bagel! Soft, chewy, fresh and crunchy and delicious all at the same time! Either butter or cream cheese..even jam! It's soooo good and I'm excited to try to plain!
Love these. It is great being able to heat them in the oven to get crispy on the outside and warm and soft on the inside. Just like a bagel shop in your own home.
Why have I never got them before. When the nearest bagel shop is over 50 miles away, these tasted like they are fresh baked. Very good.
Never had a take and bake bagel, but now I can not go back 😍 My home smells like a Panera and it was delicious with avocado spread. Perfect breakfast!
These semi-baked bagels after baking them all the way were fantastic! Tasted like fresh bagels from a bagel shop. Absolutely delicious.
Bagels are kind of doughy in the middle even when toasted. Love the Everything bagel flavor though!
That is a good bagel. Only concern are the ingredients. Takes less ingredients when I make them at home.
Amazing bagels, but beware of very high sodium on the everything bagel variant
Basic everything bagel. Good size. Will fit in a toaster.
Bagels are yummy. Loved how easy it was to bake and serve. Easy clean up.
