Chocolate Walnut Derby Pie
You’ll go nuts for this! | 2 Servings
- Eggs
- Milk
- Soy
- Tree Nuts
- Wheat
If you love brownies, you’ll love this single-serving of Derby Pie. Originally created at the Melrose Inn in Prospect, Kentucky, this dessert doesn’t actually have anything to do with the horse race. But once you taste the gooey, nutty, chocolaty goodness of this custard-style pie, you’ll be racing to get more! Nutrition values are representative of one pie.
Ingredients
2 piece
Kentucky Derby Pie
(Contains: Eggs, Milk, Soy, Tree Nuts, Wheat)
Nutrition Values
Cooking Steps
Enjoy!
Customer reviews
Review summary
Updated on Dec 2025- Flavor: Rich, chocolatey brownie taste with nutty walnut notes. Some found it deliciously gooey when warmed up 🍫.
- Ease of prep: Convenient and ready to eat, but many recommend heating for the best experience.
- Suggestions: Try adding whipped cream or vanilla ice cream on top for extra indulgence.
- Texture: The filling was praised as moist and brownie-like, though some found the crust dry or thick.
Reviews from our home cooks
Chocolate desserts are always a little better when they're warm and a bit gooey. Nice texture from the walnuts. Went perfectly with some good vanilla ice cream!
I'd never heard of this but the walnuts were an excellent kick and the chocolate was rich and amazing.
It didn't taste very chocolatey nor super sweet, which I was hoping for. There was too much crust for how little filling there was. Super disappointed cuz I was super excited to try this
Yummy! Glad they are portion controlled or I would eat a whole pie! Then I would regret it as I'm on a strict diet.
These were crazy delicious and super rich. They looked small but we each got two servings out of them. Yum!
Surprisingly good! I wasn't expecting much but this tasted like a delicious warm moist brownie.
My favorite dessert! It's especially good with whipped cream or ice cream after heating it up in the microwave.
Never had it before. It tasted so good and also fun to try something new.
These are always good! I either put vanilla ice cream or a dash of whipped cream on top.
Please be sure to heat this up. Boring if served cold or at room temperature.
