Grilled Cheese with Truffle Butter
You butter believe it. | 4 Servings
- Soy
- Wheat
- Milk
You’re never too old for grilled cheese—especially one with sourdough bread, sharp cheddar cheese, and black truffle butter! We’re sending all these ingredients for an easy-prep meal that’s sure to satisfy. No matter how you slice it, this melty sandwich is perfect at any age and at any time of day. Nutrition values are representative of a 1/4 bundle serving.
Ingredients
8 slice
Sourdough Bread
(Contains: Soy, Wheat)
8 ounce
Cheddar Cheese
(Contains: Milk)
3 ounce
Black Truffle Butter
(Contains: Milk)
Not included in your delivery
1 teaspoon
Cooking Oil
Nutrition Values
Cooking Steps
Spread sourdough with black truffle butter; place on a clean work surface, buttered sides up. Evenly top half the slices with 2-3 slices of cheddar. Top with remaining bread, buttered sides down.
Heat a drizzle of oil in a large pan over medium heat. Add sandwiches and cook until bread is golden and cheese melts, 2-3 minutes per side. (Work in batches if necessary.)
Halve on a diagonal and serve.
Customer reviews
Review summary
Updated on Sep 2026- Flavor: The truffle butter is the star — many loved its rich, distinctive taste, though it's an acquired flavor that divides opinions.
- Ease of prep: This is about as simple as it gets — butter the bread, add cheese, and pan-fry until golden.
- Suggestions: If the truffle flavor feels too strong, use less butter; some found backing off the amount made the sandwich much more enjoyable. A few reviewers added salami, pickles, avocado, or turkey pepperoni to build a heartier sandwich.
- Leftovers: Sandwiches are best fresh, but this recipe pairs beautifully with tomato soup for a quick, satisfying meal.
- Cooking tip: The truffle butter browns bread faster than regular butter — keep heat at medium and watch closely to avoid burning.
Reviews from our home cooks
The truffle butter browned the bread faster than regular salted butter. I cooked it as I'd make a normal grilled cheese, but the bread burned to black in under 2 min with the heat set to medium. It took some trial and error to cook it, but it was delicious once we got it right
Hesitant about the truffle butter but truly like the flavor it adds to the grilled cheese sandwich. Truffle butter is a wonderful complement to the sharp cheddar...don't think the butter would compliment regular cheddar or american cheese (may be good with swiss?). Keep looking for the truffle butter to be sold on its own to be purchased.
I've Never buttered the inside of a grilled cheese before, and I typically don't use sourdough. Really liked the sharp cheddar with the black truffle butter, and I liked how well the sourdough got crunchy. Good, easy, quick! Went great with my homemade tomato soup.
I really wanted to love this. Grilled cheese has always been a favorite of mine. The bread was on the small side but otherwise perfect. It had just the right thickness and crunch. The cheese was ...well...cheesy but I like just about all flavors of cheese. It was the same type I use. The truffle butter was a little more on the pungent side than I'm used to. I've never had it before and I wasn't sure I liked the smell. Overall it was good but not worth the cost for the size and quantity.
This was sooo decadent and delicious. Who knew a grilled cheese could taste so good. I will excuse the fact that the bread was missing, and I had to buy my own sourdough. The truffle butter was definitely the star of this sandwich.
The garlic truffle butter overpowers the cheese. A plain good quality butter would have tasted better.
Tastes like gourmet grilled cheese! The taste so yummy and are bigger and more filling then it looks like in the picture. We will definitely order again. These sandwiches paired with the creamy tomato soup really hits the spot on a rainy day.
Easy to make, extra truffle flavor was subtle but deepend the cheese. Highly recommend!
Would be better with a milder cheese that doesn't overpower the truffle. Maybe a Muenster or Havarti or Provolone/Mozzarella
The truffle butter takes this to another level - great break and treat for lunch during my hectic work day!
