Pumpkin Bagels
Spice is nice! | 4 Servings
- Sesame
- Wheat
Missing your PSL? We’ve got you covered with these pumpkin spice bagels! What better way to start your day than with this satisfying option? They’re crusty on the outside, moist and chewy on the inside, and packed with pumpkin spices. Toast and spread them with cream cheese or butter and jam. Nutrition values are representative of one bagel.
Ingredients
4 piece
Pumpkin Bagel
(Contains: Sesame, Wheat)
Cooking Steps
Keep frozen until ready to eat. (TIP: Do not microwave.)
OVEN OR TOASTER OVEN: Preheat oven to 425 degrees. Place on a baking sheet; bake until golden brown, 7-10 minutes. (Note: Oven times may vary.)
AIR FRYER: Arrange bagels side by side in an air fryer basket (you may have to work in batches). Air fry at 400 degrees until golden brown, 4-5 minutes. (Note: Air fryer times may vary).
Let cool, 2-3 minutes, before slicing.
Customer reviews
Review summary
Updated on Feb 2026- Flavor: Many enjoyed the subtle pumpkin taste, while others wished for a stronger flavor. Some found it comparable to plain bagels.
- Ease of prep: Air frying or baking whole yielded great results. Some suggested toasting for the best texture.
- Suggestions: Consider adding cream cheese, butter, or jam. Sprinkle with cinnamon for extra fall flavor 🍂.
- Texture: Most found them soft and chewy, though a few noted they were dense or thin.
Reviews from our home cooks
Loved that they weren't too sweet or overly pumpkin spiced. Just the right amount for a subtle pumpkin flavor. Bagels are perfectly soft and not too bready or chewy. Great for a quick breakfast or a side dipper for chili.
Put the bagel in the air fryer to 'bake' at home and was really pleased with the chewiness and flavor. Not strong on the pumpkin but not plain either.
This is probably the best bagel I've ever had, and I grew up on Noah's Bagels from New York! (We have Noah's in California) I don't buy bagels from the store because they simply cannot compare to Noah's. These bagels, however, are as good if not better than Noah's! I'm gonna have to buy these from Hellofresh every few weeks...
Smelled so good while baking and it's like the first taste of fall! Better than your average store or even bakery bagels.
These weren't as I expected but good. I bake in my iFoodie then toast them. The flavor is a mix of ginger snap & maple cookies. Not sweet at all just the right amount of spice flavor to enjoy with cream cheese on top sprinkled with cinnamon to have with my coffee.
They need to be baked whole, not sliced. Very subtle pumpkin flavor and very tasty
Soft and chewy. Really nice subtle pumpkin flavor. Will buy these again!
My bagels didn't rise much (not sure if they were supposed to), but a rather thin bagel for my taste
These are very tasty with a slight hint of pumpkin flavor.
Fresh bread. It took us 4 days to eat it, and it never got stale.
