Creamy Potato Salad
Quick and creamy spuds. | 4 Servings
- Eggs
This creamy potato salad is a great addition to any meal. Cook the potatoes in the microwave or on the stovetop, then mix in mayo, Dijon, and pickles—you’re only 15 minutes away from those comforting, delicious flavors. Whether your meal is a casual cookout or you’re sitting down to a nice dinner, this side dish is always right at home. Nutrition values are representative of a 1/4 bundle serving.
Ingredients
2 pound
Yukon Gold Potatoes
3 ounce
Mayonnaise
(Contains: Eggs)
1 unit
Dijon Mustard
1 unit
Sliced Dill Pickle
Not included in your delivery
Salt
Pepper
Nutrition Values
Cooking Steps
RECOMMENDED: Microwave sealed potato bags on high, for 11-13 minutes. Let cool completely, 10 minutes. While the potatoes cook, finely chop pickle. Halve or quarter potatoes and place in a large bowl. Add mayonnaise, Dijon mustard, and chopped pickle. Toss to evenly coat. Season with salt and pepper to taste. Serve.
STOVETOP ALTERNATIVE: Halve or quarter potatoes. Place potatoes in a large pot with enough salted water to cover by 2 inches. Bring to a boil and cook until potatoes are tender, 11-13 minutes. Drain and let cool completely, 10 minutes. While the potatoes cook, finely chop pickle. Halve or quarter potatoes and place in a large bowl. Add mayonnaise, Dijon mustard, and chopped pickle. Toss to evenly coat. Season with salt and pepper to taste. Serve. RECIPE SUGGESTION (Additional ingredients not included.): Sprinkle smoked paprika over top before serving for extra flavor and color!
Customer reviews
Review summary
Updated on Dec 2025- Flavor: Many loved the simple, classic taste; some found it a bit bland and added extra seasoning for more zing 🌶️.
- Ease of prep: Customers raved about how quick and easy it was to make, especially using the microwave method for cooking potatoes.
- Suggestions: Consider adding celery for crunch, green onions for flavor, or hard-boiled eggs for richness and texture.
- Portions: Generous serving size pleased most; some found using just one bag of potatoes was perfect for smaller households.
- Texture: A few noted the potatoes were too large; cutting them smaller improved the overall consistency.
Reviews from our home cooks
This had my mouth watering. Such a good potato salad recipe and unbelievably easy and quick!!!
This made for a pretty quick potato salad. I started around 3:30 and the potato salad was nicely chilled by 6pm. I needed to add some white vinegar to the mayo/mustard mixture. Although the pickle adds some acid it was tasting a bit sweet to me. I probably added 1 TBS. I also added in chopped celery for crunch. I only wish that the potatoes that we were sent had a longer storage date. At least give me the week. The best buy date is: 06/15/22. Since I'm only preparing for 2, I only used 1 bag of potatoes which made the perfect amount. Enough for the meal with some left for snacking or tomorrow. I also used 2 mayo & 1 mustard. Not bad.
I love this potato salad. I add a little more Dijon because I like it moist. The best part is the sour pickles. I'd love 2 pickles to make it perfect!
Everybody has their own opinions about their favorite potato salad so you can't please everyone. That said, I would have liked the addition of dill and I would have liked an option to have eggs with it. I expected a German potato salad to have vinegar and bacon in it but I love potato salad so I will probably order it again and just add a few extra things that I like. It had plenty of potatoes in it but could have used more mayo. The packet included wasn't quite enough for the volume. Nice option!
How can such a simple recipe be so heavenly!? Those potatoes are seriously the best I have ever had. They Taste naturally sweet and almost a little buttery. Pure bliss, I will get this again and I hope to see more of this potato brand in future dishes!
Good recipe, easy to make, potatoes cook in bag in microwave. I added a couple hard boiled eggs and more dill pickle. Great flavor.
Nice addition particularly since it is summer. Perfect for a picnic. Without adding additional ingredients, you may want to include in prep instruction to add the pickle juice (from the pickle packet) to the salad. Also, that it tastes best when it's had time to blend flavors. Great to make the day before. Cheers!
Wonderful and would be even better by cutting the potatoes smaller.
Good but missing something, like eggs or more pickle. Also better to cut potatoes smaller than suggested.
Plain tasting, but very good. Easy to "fix up"! Like the simplicity.
